The Benny, also called the best bower, is a joker added to the euchre deck as the highest trump of all. It sits above the right bower, belongs to whatever suit is trump, and wins any trick it's played to.
What it is
Standard North American euchre uses 24 cards and has no joker. The Benny is the main feature of British euchre, played mostly in the southwest of England (Cornwall and Devon) and the Channel Islands. One joker goes into the pack, and nothing else about the bidding changes: you still order up, pick up, or name a suit in the second round.
What does change is the top of the trump suit. The right bower is no longer a sure winner, because one card can still beat it.
The new trump order
With the Benny in play, trump has eight cards instead of seven. Here's the order when hearts are trump:
Everything else works as usual. The jack of the same color is still the left bower, and the other suits rank A, K, Q, J, 10, 9 (minus the jack that became the left bower).
The deck and the kitty
- 25 cards: the usual 9 through ace in four suits, plus one joker.
- Five cards each, dealt the usual way.
- Five left over instead of four. The top one is turned up as the upcard and the other four stay face down.
No joker in the box? Agree on a stand-in before you start. The two of spades is the usual choice.
When the Benny is turned up
The joker has no suit, so it can't offer one as trump. Tables handle this in one of three ways:
- Dealer names trump, blind. The traditional British rule. The dealer's team automatically become the makers, and the dealer names a trump suit before looking at their own hand. Then they pick up the Benny and discard one card as usual.
- Dealer names trump after looking. A friendlier version. The dealer's team are still the makers, but the dealer may look at their hand first.
- Turn it down. Some groups bury the joker and turn up the next card of the kitty instead, then bid as normal.
None of these is wrong. Pick one before the first deal, along with the rest of your house rules.
Playing the Benny
- It's trump, always. If trump is led and the Benny is your only trump, you have to play it. You can't play it to follow any other suit.
- It's a sure trick. Nothing beats it, so the Benny wins whenever it's played. The only question is when.
- Lead it to pull trump. If your side made trump and you want the defenders' trump out of play, leading the Benny takes the trick and makes everyone follow with a trump.
- Or keep it as a stopper. On defense, saving the Benny to beat the makers' right bower can be worth more than leading it.
- It makes loners easier. A hand with the Benny and both bowers holds the top three trumps. That's a strong start on going alone.
How often will you see it? In a 25-card deck you'll be dealt the Benny about one hand in five. It's turned up about once in 25 deals, and about one deal in six it sits face down in the kitty and isn't played at all.
Where it comes from
The joker in a modern deck of cards exists because of euchre. American card makers added it in the 1850s and 1860s as an extra top trump for the game, and only later did it find its way into poker and other games. North American euchre players mostly dropped it, while British players kept it, which is why the Benny is now thought of as a British rule.
An example hand
You're first seat, the upcard is the queen of spades, and you hold:
With the Benny, spades as trump gives you three trumps: the Benny, the ace and the 10. You hold no bower, but the Benny outranks both of them, so your trumps are the best, fourth-best and seventh-best cards in the suit. Ordering up the queen of spades is a reasonable call. Expect your Benny and ace to take two tricks, and look to your partner or the 10 for a third.
Questions
Is the Benny a trump card?
Yes, always. Whatever suit is trump, the Benny belongs to it. It must be played to a trump lead if it is your only trump, and it can never be played to follow another suit.
What happens if the Benny is turned up?
At most tables the dealer's team become the makers straight away. The dealer names a trump suit, picks up the Benny and discards one card. In the traditional British game the dealer names trump before looking at their hand. Some groups turn the joker down and flip the next card instead, so agree on it first.
What if my deck has no joker?
Use a spare card everyone will recognize. The two of spades is the usual stand-in.
How many cards are in the kitty with the Benny?
Five instead of four. Twenty-five cards, twenty dealt, five left over: the upcard and four face down.
Do Americans play with the Benny?
Rarely. In the United States and Canada the standard game is 24 cards with no joker. The Benny is mostly a British custom, strongest in Cornwall, Devon and the Channel Islands.
Our free euchre game uses the standard 24-card deck without the Benny, but it's still the quickest way to get a feel for the bowers. For the full card order in every suit, see Card Ranking & Bowers.